Skip to content Skip to footer

Innovation in European Competition Law

This short article serves as an introduction to Thibault Schrepel’s latest working paper, “A Systematic Content Analysis of Innovation in European Competition Law” (open-access)

***

Economies are becoming more complex, with more transactions required to produce each product.1Hausmann, Hidalgo, Bustos, Coscia, Simoes, and Yildirim, The Atlas of Economic Complexity: Mapping Paths to Prosperity (MIT Press, 2014), pp. 18-20; Hidalgo and Hausmann “The Building Blocks of Economic Complexity”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, Vol. 106, No. 26 (2009), pp. 10570-10575; McKinsey Global Institute (2013), “Disruptive Technologies: Advances that Will Transform Life, Business, and the Global Economy”; World Economic Forum (2018), “The Global Risks Report 2018”. This trend is attributed to the transition from an industrial to a knowledge-based economy, which relies heavily on digital innovation, i.e., information and communication technologies. Innovation plays a crucial role in defining competitive dynamics and market boundaries.2Damanpour, “Organizational innovation: A Meta-Analysis of Effects of Determinants and Moderators”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 34, No. 3 (1991), 555-590 (innovation is positively related to firm performance); Yang, Li, and Li, “Mechanism of Innovation and Standardization Driving Company Competitiveness in the Digital Economy” Journal of Business Economics and Management, Vol. 24, No. 1 (2023), 54-73 (the level of innovation and standardization of a company drives its competitiveness); Geroski, “Innovation as an Engine of Competition” in Mueller, Haid and Weigand (Ed.), Competition, Efficiency, and Welfare (Springer, 1991), pp. 13-26; Jorde and Teece, “Antitrust Policy and Innovation: Taking Account of Performance Competition and Competitor Cooperation”, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, Vol. 147, No. 1 (1991), pp. 118-144; Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2015), “The Innovation Imperative: Contributing to Productivity, Growth and Well-Being” (calling innovation a “key driver of economic growth and development”); Petit and Teece, Innovating Big Tech firms and competition policy: favoring dynamic over static competition, Industrial and Corporate Change, Vol. 30, No. 5 (2021), pp. 1168–1198.

In light of this, one might wonder about the conceptual role of ‘innovation’ in antitrust law. More specifically, is there a coherent theory of innovation in competition law cases? If so, what is the impact of this theory on competition law outcomes? Does the theory take into account all aspects of innovation, or does it discriminate between characteristics? Is the theory consistent with recent findings in the literature? If not, how does the lack of theory affect competition law outcomes? Does the literature provide guidance to courts and agencies on how to develop a unifying theory?

In “A Systematic Content Analysis of Innovation in European Competition Law”, Thibault Schrepel analyzes the 5 Ws of innovation, namely, who, what, when, where, and why.

Regarding the “who,” this article documents whether EU courts focus their analysis on defendants, plaintiffs, or both. With regards to the “what,” we focus on whether EU courts are dealing with product innovation (“a product innovation is a new or improved good or service that differs significantly from the firm’s previous goods or services and that has been introduced on the market”)3OECD/Eurostat (2018), Oslo Manual 2018: Guidelines for Collecting, Reporting and Using Data on Innovation, 4th Edition, The Measurement of Scientific, Technological and Innovation Activities, OECD Publishing, Paris/Eurostat, Luxembourg, pp. 70 or process innovation (“a new or improved business process for one or more business functions that differs significantly from the firm’s previous business processes and that has been brought into use in the firm”).4Oslo Manual 2018 supra note 12, pp. 72.

Regarding “when,” the present article first studies whether EU courts look at innovation in the short-term (with variables that can already be computed) or long-term (with variables that are yet to appear, e.g., after a period of 3 years). We do not distinguish whether EU courts look at the effects of past practices or whether they (also) discuss the current and future effects on innovation and related incentives. EU courts discuss past and present variables to infer future effects, which would have made the distinction artificial.

In terms of “where,” a first distinction is made between digital (used as a synonym for information and communication technologies) and non-digital cases, as EU courts may attach different attributes to innovation in related sectors. A second distinction is between considerations relating to innovation within the relevant market, as defined in each case, and innovation outside the relevant market. This distinction correlates with the analysis of incremental (i.e., extensions or modifications of existing products)5Ali, “Pioneering Versus Incremental Innovation: Review and Research Propositions”, Vol. 11, No. 1 (1994) Journal of Product Innovation Management, pp. 46-61 at 48. or disruptive innovation (i.e., products outside the relevant market with attributes initially inferior to those of existing products).6Larson, “Disruptive Innovation Theory: What It Is & 4 Key Concepts”, Harvard Business School Online (2016).

Finally, with regard to the “why,” this study documents whether EU courts consider the relationship between competition and innovation from an “incentive effect” or an “impact effect” perspective. The incentive effect refers to the idea that competition drives innovation (what we will call a competition-driven market, or “CDM”). The impact effect refers to the opposite idea of which innovation drives competition (which we will call an innovation-driven market, or “IDM”). We document the legal implications of these two competing conceptions of the relationship between competition and innovation. Finally, we also document whether EU courts view innovation as a survival strategy (i.e., a necessity) or as a driving strategy (i.e., leading the market or ecosystem in the desired direction).

For the rest, i.e., the in-depth analysis of the case law listed in these tables, and proposals to contribute to a theory of innovation in EU competition law that is applied with more consistency and take more parameters into account, seeA Systematic Content Analysis of Innovation in European Competition Law”.

Thibault Schrepel
@ProfSchrepel

65 Comments

  • 🔴 Baшe вoзнaгpaждeниe ->> https://forms.yandex.ru/cloud/6547f88bd04688f1a57043ac/?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& # CW605 🔴
    Posted 6 November 2023 21:56 0Likes

    anmy4r

  • eski rahatiniz olmayacak
    Posted 29 December 2023 17:59 0Likes

    yandanxvurulmus.yK4o7b81wZIq

  • foreladies
    Posted 29 December 2023 21:58 0Likes

    xbunedirloooo.o3JmSOaRVNo0

  • faineantise
    Posted 30 December 2023 09:00 0Likes

    faineantise xyandanxvurulmus.aIxHYf6AhkwN

  • am siteleri
    Posted 16 January 2024 16:14 0Likes

    craft porn vurgunyedim.K1wONSWRgEjx

  • watch porn video
    Posted 17 January 2024 08:01 0Likes

    bahis siteleri sikis yaralandinmieycan.yZcyLbQeZIEt

  • bahis siteleri incest category
    Posted 20 January 2024 09:24 0Likes

    fuck google citixx.MGRYJSyREaJ5

  • porn
    Posted 20 January 2024 09:47 0Likes

    sektor benim zaten amin evladi hyuqgzhqt.003vH72x3Qfz

  • eski rahatiniz olmayacak
    Posted 20 January 2024 09:56 0Likes

    amciik siteleri ewrjghsdfaa.oHcygwiDjk8g

  • porn siteleri
    Posted 20 January 2024 10:38 0Likes

    food porn wrtgdfgdfgdqq.oQ3XcX6M0gKi

  • fuck google
    Posted 2 February 2024 12:37 0Likes

    childrens sex pompadirha.vFPkuw3nSUq0

  • food porn
    Posted 2 February 2024 12:52 0Likes

    seksi siteler asillartaklitler.MIGOKvSe7ldl

  • escort
    Posted 2 February 2024 17:35 0Likes

    anal sikis siteleri hephupx.nfOzYcqiqa9W

  • sexax
    Posted 3 February 2024 13:08 0Likes

    bahis siteleri sikis hepxhupx.2uCCqk7bJR6k

  • porn siteleri
    Posted 3 February 2024 14:03 0Likes

    porn siteleri juljulfbi.e8wCMZ8F0K9B

  • bahis siteleri sikis
    Posted 5 February 2024 08:04 0Likes

    porn bjluajszz.42i7nmLfNad9

  • bahis siteleri sikis
    Posted 5 February 2024 08:23 0Likes

    viagra bxjluajsxzz.5MjxdioryHlt

  • bahis siteleri porn
    Posted 5 February 2024 08:43 0Likes

    watch porn video 0qbxjluaxcxjsxzz.R31soKP2IsmE

  • 🔶 Yоu hаvе еаrnеd 21 326 US dollars. Gо tо withdrаwаl >> https://forms.yandex.com/cloud/65c5cc605d2a0646042900c4/?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& 🔶
    Posted 10 February 2024 04:53 0Likes

    ccuky1

  • ⭕ You got 44 049 US dollars. GЕТ > https://forms.yandex.com/cloud/65c5cc5a2530c245feb4aa15/?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& ⭕
    Posted 13 February 2024 17:18 0Likes

    xo7sf6

  • 🔶 Transfer 18 799 Dollars. GЕТ => https://forms.yandex.com/cloud/65cc7b3369387229ff45e92e/?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& 🔶
    Posted 15 February 2024 04:34 0Likes

    9jpy5l

  • 🔰 Yоu hаvе еаrnеd 40 131 USD. Gо tо withdrаwаl > https://forms.yandex.com/cloud/65c3b4de3e9d08158a59a30a/?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& 🔰
    Posted 18 February 2024 11:10 0Likes

    k3l1dn

  • * * * 🎁 GET FREE iPhone 15: http://izmirlianfoundation.am/files/go.php 🎁 * * * hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174*
    Posted 19 February 2024 21:18 0Likes

    6r6h5g

  • porn
    Posted 21 February 2024 08:41 0Likes

    eski rahatiniz olmayacak pokkerx.pZ5NQTzh5r6f

  • pornhub bahis siteleri
    Posted 21 February 2024 08:57 0Likes

    porno siteleri mobileidn.iCR2ucPBH32i

  • craft porn
    Posted 21 February 2024 09:03 0Likes

    porn siteleri bingoxx.haEv7qXTFAvl

  • escort
    Posted 21 February 2024 09:45 0Likes

    eski rahatiniz olmayacak 250tldenemebonusuxx.epCNx3067LgX

  • escort siteleri
    Posted 21 February 2024 11:54 0Likes

    porno izle eyeconartxx.0wdXaCin2GFn

  • eskort siteleri
    Posted 22 February 2024 18:10 0Likes

    viagra vvsetohimalxxvc.96h0ZAC6yjrs

  • porno siteleri
    Posted 23 February 2024 22:00 0Likes

    childrens sex tthighereduhryyy.iZz1r6oQCnx

  • 🔄 You got 32 563 US dollars. Gо tо withdrаwаl =>> https://forms.yandex.com/cloud/65d4a49f73cee73c2452da8d?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& 🔄
    Posted 24 February 2024 03:46 0Likes

    qeowvv

  • 🔆 Withdrawing 31 027 USD. GЕТ >>> https://forms.yandex.ru/cloud/65d4adaf90fa7b3c87614294?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& 🔆
    Posted 24 February 2024 15:58 0Likes

    b8sdii

  • new free hd porn
    Posted 13 March 2024 09:02 0Likes

    సెక్స్ డౌన్లోడ్ gghkyogg.7Oq0J14VROg

  • download 4k pron
    Posted 13 March 2024 14:57 0Likes

    hd porno free ggjennifegg.eLLc9fNIU2T

  • free porn videos hd
    Posted 13 March 2024 16:52 0Likes

    best porn 4k ggjinnysflogg.7iL174Phhrp

  • * * * Apple iPhone 15 Free: http://ayushmaanpharma.com/uploads/go.php * * * hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174*
    Posted 16 March 2024 17:53 0Likes

    u624dy

  • * * * Apple iPhone 15 Free * * * hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174*
    Posted 16 March 2024 17:54 0Likes

    qccqme

  • ⭕ Transaction 39 724 $. GЕТ => https://telegra.ph/BTC-Transaction--205180-03-14?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& ⭕
    Posted 18 March 2024 07:07 0Likes

    fui0z7

  • Allen
    Posted 20 March 2024 04:31 0Likes

    Wow, fantastic weblog structure! How lengthy have you
    been running a blog for? you made running a blog
    look easy. The total look of your site is excellent, as
    well as the content material! You can see similar here sklep internetowy

  • Billy
    Posted 20 March 2024 20:19 0Likes

    Wow, superb weblog layout! How lengthy have you
    ever been blogging for? you made running a blog look easy.
    The whole glance of your site is fantastic, let alone the content material!
    You can see similar here sklep internetowy

  • Retha
    Posted 22 March 2024 00:52 0Likes

    Wow, superb blog structure! How long have you been blogging for?

    you made blogging glance easy. The whole glance of your site is wonderful, as smartly as the content!
    You can see similar here e-commerce

  • Elizabeth
    Posted 22 March 2024 07:48 0Likes

    Excellent blog here! Also your website loads up fast!

    What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host?
    I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol I saw
    similar here: Dobry sklep

  • Woodrow
    Posted 22 March 2024 22:14 0Likes

    Wow, amazing blog format! How long have you been running a blog for?
    you make running a blog look easy. The whole look of your web site is magnificent, let alone the content material!
    You can see similar here ecommerce

  • Rickey
    Posted 24 March 2024 14:03 0Likes

    Good day! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with
    SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
    If you know of any please share. Cheers! You can read similar
    article here: Sklep internetowy

  • fashionflag hd best porn videos
    Posted 27 March 2024 09:30 0Likes

    fashionflag porn movies download 4k fashionflag.aaT7i2zqvD6

  • goodhere Mixed porn
    Posted 28 March 2024 05:29 0Likes

    goodhere Orgy porn vurucutewet.z8BOy5hCJrm

  • ladyandtherose Shemale porn
    Posted 28 March 2024 08:55 0Likes

    ladyandtherose Funny Porn backlinkseox.LxYDNMFKBA7

  • jenniferroy 集団セックス
    Posted 28 March 2024 15:31 0Likes

    jenniferroy 大きなお尻ポルノ japanesexxporns.oCb1jvrTBHK

  • Dustin
    Posted 28 March 2024 19:08 0Likes

    Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with
    SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing
    very good gains. If you know of any please share.

    Appreciate it! You can read similar text here: E-commerce

  • landuse Handjob porn
    Posted 29 March 2024 08:15 0Likes

    landuse Funny Porn lancdcuse.agYMLTFhlqw

  • falbobrospizzamadison Small Tits porn
    Posted 29 March 2024 15:17 0Likes

    falbobrospizzamadison Teens porn jkkıjxxx.PFBcgW287Ao

  • ✅ + 0,75 ВTC. Continue >>> https://telegra.ph/BTC-Transaction--322654-03-14?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& ✅
    Posted 29 March 2024 22:49 0Likes

    l2ka98

  • शौकिया अश्लील
    Posted 30 March 2024 07:42 0Likes

    नानी अश्लील qqyyooppxx.TrkXJxGS0YM

  • बड़का मुर्गा पोर्न के बा
    Posted 30 March 2024 15:41 0Likes

    अंतरजातीय अश्लीलता के बारे में बतावल गइल बा hjkvbasdfzxzz.XmmfSl9qp8t

  • विंटेज पोर्न
    Posted 1 April 2024 11:07 0Likes

    बीबीडब्ल्यू अश्लील txechdyzxca.DI4LfEMy414

  • हस्तमैथुन अश्लील
    Posted 2 April 2024 18:28 0Likes

    बड़ा गधा अश्लील hkyonet.5sHWWDCrayD

  • ਮਿਸ਼ਨਰੀ ਸ਼ੈਲੀ ਪੋਰਨ
    Posted 3 April 2024 16:08 0Likes

    ਜਾਅਲੀ ਟੈਕਸੀ ਪੋਰਨ madisonivysex.x3f4AkA78XS

  • Myrtis
    Posted 3 April 2024 20:05 0Likes

    Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my website to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very
    good results. If you know of any please share.
    Appreciate it! You can read similar blog here: List of Backlinks

  • Una
    Posted 4 April 2024 15:04 0Likes

    Good day! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with SEO?
    I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing
    very good results. If you know of any please share. Cheers!
    You can read similar blog here: List of Backlinks

  • Suzanne
    Posted 4 April 2024 20:53 0Likes

    Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help
    with SEO? I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not
    seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
    Thank you! You can read similar text here: Scrapebox List

  • ladesbet ਵਾਲਾਂ ਵਾਲਾ ਪੋਰਨ
    Posted 5 April 2024 05:35 0Likes

    ladesbet ਫੈਟਿਸ਼ ਪੋਰਨੋਗ੍ਰਾਫੀ ਹੈ ladesinemi.1CeWo1p1zs0

  • ladesbet ポルノのキャスティング
    Posted 5 April 2024 07:16 0Likes

    ladesbet 老若男女のポルノ ladestinemi.bpWIWT0eQLF

  • ↔ You got 51 926 Dollars. Gо tо withdrаwаl > https://script.google.com/macros/s/AKfycbytXUCXQbLhxAAywDwcOnCr5BQ6IXaqdZm9m2zXFCC2ZC3cnaU13ETTovgrzsGyz8Ef7Q/exec?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& ↔
    Posted 6 April 2024 07:29 0Likes

    ph0xug

  • Alphonso
    Posted 6 April 2024 07:34 0Likes

    Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to help
    with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to
    rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
    If you know of any please share. Kudos! You can read similar
    text here: Link Building

  • ✅ Transfer 68 697 $. Gо tо withdrаwаl >> https://script.google.com/macros/s/AKfycbw3J5mUfgyqorl9f2fHu4sztLp9sTINsg-XlDndyNZUV4Z-DQJm9RRjWM3oDycHujrM/exec?hs=6a761a19486c8a55a58baaed5eb0e174& ✅
    Posted 7 April 2024 21:02 0Likes

    fn0i8d

Leave a comment

Subscribe to our newsletter