An excerpt from “Law + Technology” you can download here.
***
1. Hypothesis
Instead of the classical “law & technology” approach, this article proposes to adopt a “law + technology” approach to explore the synergies between law and technology. “Law + technology” is based on a simple postulate: technology and law can better increase the common good together than in a silo.
Law and technology are made of different materials: law is first and foremost a social constraint, technology is above all a technical constraint. These materials are complements, so one material must not erode the other.1The erosion risk exists when the two materials (law and technology) collide. This risk does not always have to be avoided. When law and technology present irreconcilable interests, the law must prevail in a rule of law system. For example, freedom of expression must prevail over censorship technologies used by the Chinese and Russian governments. The task assigned to lawyers under a “law + technology” approach is thus to regulate the negative ramifications of technology while preserving the positive ones. The approach requires policymakers and regulators to study and understand the technology’s positive ramifications before regulating it. Under “law and technology,” the risk of unintentionally reducing these positive ramifications is much higher.2Under a “law & technology” approach, regulators are not comparing the effect of different intervention methods on the positive ramification of technology. They are not in a position to balance the effectiveness of the rule and its effect on the technology. Regulators may choose a regulation with comparable efficiency to others but a more negative impact on the technology.
2. Approach
Technology can only play a role in “law + technology” if legal rules do not hamper it. Darwin’s work helps understand what preserving technology entails. In his book On the Origin of Species, the father of modern biology concludes that animal species and varieties can only survive if they have unique characteristics they can put to good use in their environment. It follows that the natural or brutal change in the environment causes species extinction.3Charles Darwin, On The Origin Of Species, 69 (1859, John Murray) (“if these enemies or competitors be in the least degree favoured by any slight change of climate, they will increase in numbers, and, as each area is already fully stocked with inhabitants, the other species will decrease”). The same is true if man’s hand changes the characteristics of these species.4Charles Darwin, On The Origin Of Species, 38, 84 (1859, John Murray) (“Man can hardly select, or only with much difficulty, any deviation of structure (…) How fleeting are the wishes and efforts of man! How short his time! And consequently how poor will his products be, compared with those accumulated by nature during whole geological periods. Can we wonder, then, that nature’s productions should be far ‘truer’ in character than man’s productions; that they should be infinitely better adapted to the most complex conditions of life, and should plainly bear the stamp of far higher workmanship?”).
Darwin’s work introduces what will later be called “complexity science.”5For an introduction, see John H. Holland, Complexity: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford, 2014); Stefan Thurner, Rudolf Hanel & Peter Klimek, Introduction to the Theory of Complex Systems (Oxford, 2018); M. Mitchell Waldrop, Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos (Simon & Schuster, 1992); Melanie Mitchell, Complexity: A Guided Tour (Oxford, 2009). Complexity science is interested in how systems react to the context they create. The relationships between agents create a dynamic that changes the environment in which they evolve. The new environment impacts its agents, which modify their relationships, etc.
Complexity science is not well explored in the “law & technology” literature, although its teachings are fundamental.6HeinOnline lists only 87 articles mentioning “complexity science” or “complexity theory” in the “Science, Technology, and the Law” literature between 1960 and 2020, see (all_topics_ms: “Science, Technology, and the Law” (“complexity science” OR “complexity theory”)) in Law Journal Library, section type “articles”, 1960 to 2020. The related literature body has two main lessons for regulators acting in the digital space. First, one must be careful not to remove—by legal rule—what distinguishes one technology from another, for example, not to force a single point of access in blockchain governance or constrain deep learning’s reliance on activation functions.7Chigozie Enyinna Nwankpa, Winifred Ijomah, Anthony Gachagan & Stephen Marshall, Activation Functions: Comparison of Trends in Practice and Research For Deep Learning (2018) (explains that activation functions manipulate the data and produce an output for the neural network). The changed technology will disappear in favor of others otherwise.8This proposition is only valid if what differentiates one technology from another allows for value creation. If this is not the case, technology can create value in the same way that another technology can. It may also mean that the technology survives only because of its ability to reduce the common good while benefiting a few individuals. Policymakers can therefore suppress the technology. A technology appears and remains among others only because it creates value in a singular way. Removing the element(s) that differentiate the technology from others impacts that value and thus makes it disappear. Second, one shall be cautious when changing the (legal, technical, etc.) technology environment. The technology shall remain in a position to exploit its singularities.
In practice, regulators face two scenarios. One, the technology needs to be regulated because it creates negative ramifications for reasons (technical, governance, etc.) that are not related to differentiating characteristics. Regulation can address the problems without endangering the technology’s survival. Two, the technology creates negative ramifications precisely because of the characteristics that differentiate it from others. Regulation will endanger technology’s survival, which entails addressing the issue while maintaining sufficient differentiation from other technologies.
Let’s take three examples. A blockchain smart contract is immutable. It cannot be deleted, stopped, or changed.9Thibault Schrepel, Smart Contracts and the Digital Single Market Through the Lens of a ‘Law + Technology’ Approach, European Commission, 22 (2021) (explains smart contracts’ immutability). Immutability constrains the creator of the smart contract and the regulator, which is problematic when the smart contract automates an illegal transaction. In reaction, the draft version of Data Act Article 30 proposes implementing a “mechanism (…) to terminate the continued execution of transactions.”10The Proposal for a Regulation of The European Parliament and of The Council on Harmonised Rules on Fair Access to and Use of Data (Data Act), COM(2022) 68 Final, art. 30 only applies to smart contracts automating data sharing. It would put smart contract immutability in check, thus challenging technology’s survival.11Thibault Schrepel, The Theory of Granularity in Blockchain + Antitrust: The Decentralization Formula, 247 (Edward Elgar, 2021) (explores how to make immutability practicable without hampering smart contracts’ survival chances). Immutability indeed differentiates smart contracts from other contractual methods; it creates value. The characteristic creates trust between the parties by preventing unilateral non-execution. It also lowers transaction costs related to monitoring and enforcement.12Ibid., 95-96 (smart contracts’ automatic execution reduces costs compared to using an intermediary). And it helps combat corruption by blocking malicious changes after one puts the smart contract on the network, etc. Users are unlikely to want to use a “stoppable smart contract” rather than another transactional means. This singular characteristic must therefore be regulated, but maintained.13Thibault Schrepel, Smart Contracts and the Digital Single Market Through the Lens of a ‘Law + Technology’ Approach, European Commission (2021) (applies the “law + technology” approach to smart contracts).
Similarly, blockchain immutability is problematic when courts identify past transactions as illegal, when a user sends a token to the wrong address, etc. But immutability serves the probity of the information on the blockchain. For example, if an AI system—that runs on top of a blockchain—malfunctions, the company operating the system cannot delete entries from the database to hide the reasons explaining the misbehavior.14Ibid., 56 (“blockchain visibility ensures the transparency of the data used in AI systems”). Here again, the same feature is the source of both negative and positive ramifications.
Last, one sees the duality of technology at a more general level. A facial recognition system can discriminate against minorities poorly represented in the database used to train the system using deep learning.15Joy Buolamwini & Timnit Gebru, Gender Shades: Intersectional Accuracy Disparities in Commercial Gender Classification, 81 Proc. Of Mach. Lear. Res. 1, 12 (2018) (links error rates with datasets); Karen Hao, This Is How AI Bias Really Happens—And Why It’s So Hard to Fix, MIT Tech. Rev. (Feb. 4, 2019) https://perma.cc/6QDV-WXDQ. But law enforcement can use facial recognition to identify human trafficking victims, in which case AI imperfections—if AI performs better than humans—shall be tolerated.16OSCE Office of the Special Representative and Co-ordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings and Tech Against Trafficking, Leveraging Innovation to Fight Trafficking In Human Beings: A Comprehensive Analysis of Technology Tools (Vienna, May 2020). Researchers also use deep learning systems in medicine to discover new pathologies, improve diagnoses17Nan Wu et al., Deep Neural Networks Improve Radiologists’ Performance in Breast Cancer Screening, 39 IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 1184 (2020); Charlotte Jee, Deepmind Has Made a Prototype Product That Can Diagnose Eye Diseases, MIT Tech. Rev. (Apr. 1, 2019) https://perma.cc/3QLZ-78SH. and treatments.18Anne Trafton, Artificial Intelligence Yields New Antibiotic, MIT News Office (Feb. 20, 2020) https://perma.cc/3QPR-7FT4. The same goes for metaverses and virtual reality, also used in medicine.19Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, A Game Changer: Virtual Reality Reduces Pain and Anxiety in Children (Aug. 25, 2021) https://perma.cc/2BZ4-KA65. Regulators shall consider the impact on positive ramifications instead of simply looking at a way to address the risks. The Darwinian take on regulating technology preserves these positive ramifications and thus forms the cornerstone of “law + technology.”
Thibault Schrepel
@ProfSchrepel
***
Download the entire article over here.
The following sections explore how to implement “law + technology” in practice.
239 Comments
Charlene
I could not refrain from commenting. Exceptionally well written!
Leopoldo
I think the admin of this site is in fact working hard for his site, since
here every information is quality based stuff.セクシー ランジェリー
Inforinn
“These Women High Heel Bridal Sandals are the epitome of elegance and style, adding a touch of glamour to any wedding ensemble!”
Johnathan
I really like what you guys tend to be up too. This kind of clever work and
exposure! Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve
added you guys to my personal blogroll.ダッチワイフ
Melaine
Tucker Carlson Putin Interview Video.
Joseph Stalin.
Dante
Greetings! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?
I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having
problems finding one? Thanks a lot!セクシー コスプレ
Kelle
I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This kind of
clever work and reporting! Keep up the fantastic works guys I’ve
you guys to my blogroll.ベビー ドール ランジェリー
Shenna
Wow, wonderful weblog format! How lengthy have you ever been running a
blog for? you make blogging glance easy. The full look of your web site is excellent, as
neatly as the content material! You can see similar here dobry sklep
Jodi
Wow, amazing weblog layout! How lengthy have you been running a
blog for? you make running a blog glance easy.
The overall look of your web site is wonderful, let alone the
content! You can see similar here najlepszy sklep
Veda
Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an extremely long comment but after I clicked submit
my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyway, just wanted to say excellent blog!
I saw similar here: Sklep online
Faith
Wow, incredible weblog format! How lengthy have you been running a blog for?
you made running a blog look easy. The overall glance of your site
is wonderful, let alone the content! You can see similar here najlepszy sklep
Florida
Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my
blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m
not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share.
Appreciate it! You can read similar text here: Sklep online
Rastrear Teléfono Celular
Cuando intenta espiar el teléfono de alguien, debe asegurarse de que no encuentren el software una vez que esté instalado.
Lucia
Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help
with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for
some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains.
If you know of any please share. Kudos! You can read similar text here: Sklep internetowy
Rastrear teléfono
Instalación simple y descarga gratuita, no se requieren conocimientos técnicos y no se requiere raíz.Grabacion de llamadas, Grabacion de entorno, Ubicaciones GPS, Mensajes Whatsapp y Facebook, Mensajes SMS y muchas características mas.
Paulina
Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted
keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please
share. Many thanks! I saw similar text here: Backlink Portfolio
lisinopril 40 mg brand name in india
60 mg lisinopril
Dyan
Wow, awesome blog layout! How lengthy have you been running a blog for?
you made running a blog look easy. The entire look of your web site is great, let alone the content!
You can see similar here sklep online
generic zestoretic
40 mg lisinopril for sale
Daniele
психолог стоимость w-495.ru
Adriene
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About Prettiest Pornstars prettiest Pornstars
Jolene
Get To Know The Steve Jobs Of The Best Seo Backlink Software Industry Best backlinking software
Starla
5 Clarifications Regarding Accident Injury Attorney Honolulu Accident Attorney
Wally
Why We Love 10kg Wash Machine (And You Should Too!) new washing machine 10kg
Marty
10 Healthy Habits For A Healthy Window Replacement Cost window replacement cost
uk (http://www.huenhue.net/bbs/board.php?bo_table=review&wr_id=199667)
Lizzie
Content Strategy Marketing Tools To Streamline Your Daily Life Content Strategy Marketing Trick That Every Person Should Learn Content Strategy marketing
Fawn
The Next Big Event In The Window Repair Near Industry upvc window repair near me
Gerard
The Most Worst Nightmare About Avon New Book Bring To Life
avon book May
Winnie
10 Steps To Begin Your Own Ford Key Replacement Near Me Business ford kuga key replacement (Eartha)
Kraig
10 Things We Do Not Like About Auto Ghost Immobiliser auto Ghost Immobiliser
Mariel
Incontestable Evidence That You Need Washer Tumble Dryer Combo
Washer And Dryer Combination
Nolan
10 Facts About Combination Washer And Dryers That Insists
On Putting You In An Optimistic Mood washing machines
on Sale (chessdatabase.science)
prinivil 20 mg
lisinopril price without insurance
Augustina
A Step-By Step Guide To Avon Brochures Brochure Online
Irving
Guide To Top Accident Attorneys: The Intermediate Guide
Towards Top Accident Attorneys top accident Attorneys
Ines
Many Of The Most Exciting Things That Are Happening With Window Handle Replacement
Replacement window handle [gokseong.Multiiq.Com]
Sanford
How To Tell If You’re Set For Ford Replacement Key Cost Uk Ford Transit key
Ernie
The Little Known Benefits Of Self Emptying Robot Vacuum And Mop best self emptying vacuum
Gita
15 Of The Best Pinterest Boards Of All Time About Pvc Window Repairs window
doctor (http://fhoy.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=2172231)
Flor
You’ll Be Unable To Guess Dreame L30 Ultra Review’s Tricks dreame L30 Ultra
review (proect.org)
Heike
24 Hours To Improve Bentley Continental Gt Key Fob Bentley Key Replacement
Justina
A The Complete Guide To Avon Spray Skin So Soft From Beginning To
End skin So Soft
Vivien
Why No One Cares About Avon Today Perfume avon today perfume (http://www.aliyunminisite.com/wp-content/themes/begin/inc/go.php?url=https://www.reps-r-us.co.uk/avon-perfume)
Glory
What’s The Current Job Market For Double Glazing Door Repairs Near
Me Professionals Like? Double glazing (leewhan.Com)
Margo
The 15 Things Your Boss Wished You Knew About Tommy Hilfiger Crossbody
Handbags tommy hilfiger handbag tote, forexmob.Ru,
Shantell
How To Outsmart Your Boss In Double Glazed Window Repair Near Me price
Jens
What Experts In The Field Want You To Know linton Cerebral Palsy attorney
Norine
A Peek In The Secrets Of Mobile Diagnostic Diagnostics
Maria
Five Killer Quora Answers On Michael Kors Bags Pink michael kors Bags pink
Jacqueline
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About Cheap Sofas For Sale Cheap sofas for sale
Gina
The 10 Scariest Things About Bentley Car Keys Bentley Car Key
Jeremy
Are Mobile Car Diagnostic Near Me The Most Effective Thing That Ever Was?
how much Is a car diagnostics test
Caryn
How Double Glazing Doors Near Me Has Become The Most Sought-After
Trend Of 2023 double glazing Doors
Janna
The 10 Most Scariest Things About Veterans Disability Attorneys Veterans Disability Attorneys
Kathaleen
It’s Enough! 15 Things About Marc Jacobs Black Handbag We’re Tired Of Hearing marc jacobs small tote bag – http://rutelochki.ru/user/orchidbumper57/ –
Micah
25 Surprising Facts About Deep Sectional Sofa
Sectional sofas Sleeper sofas
Sammy
Guide To Garden Wood Burner: The Intermediate Guide Towards Garden Wood
Burner garden Wood burner, community.rivernetwork.Org,
Sophie
20 Top Tweets Of All Time Concerning Private ADHD Test Uk Adhd Assessment Private
Refugia
The Secret Life Of Car Diagnostic Garage Near Me dtc
Helene
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About Kayleigh Wanless Pornstar kayleigh wanless pornstar
Jamison
10 Methods To Build Your Injury Lawyer Empire Injury Attorney
Merry
11 Ways To Completely Revamp Your Audi Keys Replacement replacement key Audi
Kai
16 Must-Follow Pages On Facebook For Upvc Window Repairs Marketers upvc window repairs near me (Mozelle)
Helena
See What Replacement Sash Windows Tricks The Celebs Are Using Replacement Sash Windows
Remona
Looking For Inspiration? Try Looking Up Slot Demo Pragmatic Demo Habanero
Darcy
The 10 Most Scariest Things About Double Glazing Repairs Near Me Double Glazing Repairs Near Me
Kayla
This Is The Kayleigh Wanless Pornstar Case Study You’ll Never Forget playboy
Milla
You’ll Be Unable To Guess Cost Of Replacement Windows Uk’s Benefits
cost of replacement windows uk
Theo
Are Private Psychiatrist Northern Ireland As Crucial As Everyone Says?
Psychiatrist leeds Private
Joe
9 Signs That You’re The Best Robot Vacuum 2023 Expert Best Robot Vacuum Under 200
Danuta
14 Common Misconceptions Concerning Designer Handbags Large designer handbags for sale
Julie
Fridge Freezer: A Simple Definition Small Fridge With Freezer
Dominic
15 Ideas For Gifts For The Erb’s Palsy Attorneys Lover In Your Life Missouri City Erb’s Palsy Law Firm
Madeleine
A Provocative Remark About CSGO Cases Explained Chroma 2 Case
Vickey
Speak “Yes” To These 5 Avon Ultimate Welcome Kit
Tips Avon Kit (https://Sixn.Net/Home.Php?Mod=Space&Uid=285690)
Adell
5 Killer Quora Answers On Tattooed Pornstars tattooed pornstars
Wyatt
20 Myths About Good Accident Lawyers: Dispelled Accident lawyer Near me
Arturo
10 Of The Top Mobile Apps To Which Is The Best Online Supermarket
Professional Mahogany Picture Frame
Mikel
9 Things Your Parents Taught You About Double Glazing Window Repairs Near
Me window repairs near me
Finlay
Here’s A Little-Known Fact About Audi Car Key Replacement
Cost replacement Key For audi
Mazie
You’ll Never Guess This Best Online Shopping Sites Clothes’s
Tricks Online Shop
Nolan
The 3 Most Significant Disasters In Best Robot Vacuums
History Robot Vacuum With Docking Station
Louvenia
How To Create Successful Mesothelioma Lawyers Tutorials On Home mesothelioma Attorney
Shirley
Five Killer Quora Answers On Treadmills Home Gym Treadmills home gym
Boyd
15 Up-And-Coming Upvc Windows Repair Bloggers You Need To Keep An Eye On Upvc Window Repairs
Tracy
The People Who Are Closest To Ford Car Keys Tell You Some Big Secrets Ford Program Key
Manual
Ford Car Key Replacement 101: A Complete Guide For Beginners ford kuga key replacement
Sammy
See What Spare Car Keys Cut Tricks The Celebs Are Using Spare Car Keys Cut
Vida
15 Things You’ve Never Known About Car Opener Service Unlock Your car
Teodoro
What The 10 Most Worst Michael Kors Handbags Failures Of All Time Could Have Been Prevented Kors Michael Handbag
Lanny
A Look Into The Future What’s The Shark I
Robot Vacuum Industry Look Like In 10 Years? cheap
Fausto
What The 10 Most Worst Online Shop Mistakes Of All Time Could Have Been Prevented online shopping sites for clothes
Malinda
7 Things You Didn’t Know About Ghost Immobiliser Near Me ghost immobiliser near
me, Danilo,
Reina
15 Things You Don’t Know About Buy Mobility Scooter best mobility scooters for sale Near me
Josette
Why Bmw Key Replacement Near Me Is The Best Choice For You?
bmw key Fob
Beth
Nine Things That Your Parent Taught You About Treadmills For Sale UK treadmills for sale uk
Lela
Why BMW Battery Replacement Key Is Relevant 2023 Bmw Series 1 key
Alfie
What’s The Current Job Market For Dreame L30 Review Professionals Like?
Dreame L30 Review
Nellie
See What Spare Car Keys Cut Tricks The Celebs Are Utilizing spare car keys cut (wavebaker28.bravejournal.net)
Lucio
The Reason Why Fiat 500 Key Replacement Cost Is Everyone’s Obsession In 2023
fiat car Keys
Frieda
20 Tools That Will Make You More Effective At Windows Repairs
Near Me window replacement near me
Luca
Are The Advances In Technology Making Best Home Espresso Machine Better Or Worse?
Sleek Design
Jesus
11 Ways To Completely Redesign Your Slot Demo Pragmatic Demo Gates Of Olympus
Zoila
Nine Things That Your Parent Taught You About Walking Pad Desk walking pad Desk
Ellen
10 Misconceptions Your Boss Has About Integrated Side By Side Fridge Freezer small side by
side refrigerator (Shoshana)
Lakeisha
Five Killer Quora Answers To Accident Injury Attorneys Near Me accident Injury Attorney (accidentinjurylawyers.Claims)
Marty
How To Create Successful What CSGO Case Has The Best Odds Tips From Home Weapon Case
Sherrill
Three Greatest Moments In Kayleigh Wanless Pornstar History uk pornstar
Dominic
9 Things Your Parents Teach You About Repairing Upvc Windows repairing upvc windows (dyer-dyer.hubstack.net)
Alexandria
Guide To Best Robot Vacuum For Carpet: The Intermediate Guide The Steps To Best Robot Vacuum
For Carpet robot
Leigh
Don’t Buy Into These “Trends” Concerning Best Accident Attorney Near Me
injury attorney near me (Lucille)
Chanda
5 Killer Quora Answers On Best Self Emptying Robot Vacuum best self emptying Robot vacuum
Athena
11 “Faux Pas” You’re Actually Able To Use With Your Best Onlyfans Pornstar top pornstars
Kristina
Online Shop: It’s Not As Expensive As You Think 1 gauge Copper Wire
Karine
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About Couches For Sale Near Me couches for sale near Me
Muhammad
Five Killer Quora Answers On Treadmills UK treadmills; https://e-directory2u.com/listings12626106/15-twitter-accounts-you-should-follow-to-discover-more-About-tread-mills,
Damon
Guide To Upvc Repairs Near Me: The Intermediate Guide Towards Upvc
Repairs Near Me upvc repairs near me (0553721256.Ussoft.kr)
Shaunte
You’ll Never Guess This Birth Injury Attorneys Near Me’s Secrets birth injury attorneys Near me
Jeana
What Is The Reason Male Sex Toys Uk Is Right For You Best Male Sex Toys
Gertrude
A Brief History Of Couches Near Me For Sale History Of Couches Near Me For Sale cream couches – willysforsale.com,
Mildred
Three Reasons To Identify Why Your Large Sectional Sofa Isn’t Working (And
How To Fix It) l-Shaped couches
Winifred
5 Killer Quora Answers On Bmw Car Key Replacement
Bmw Car Key Replacement
Meagan
15 Best Pinterest Boards Of All Time About
Good Robot Vacuum home
Lucie
What’s The Point Of Nobody Caring About Ghost 2 Immobiliser Fitting Near Me install
Rosalina
Five Killer Quora Answers To Car Key Locksmith Near Me Car key locksmith near Me
Petra
10 Signs To Watch For To Know Before You Buy Upvc Window
Repairs upvc window repairs near me (Piper)
Thanh
Why Mesothelioma Lawyers Is Relevant 2023 Asbestos Exposure Compensation Lawyer
Wilmer
How To Outsmart Your Boss Repairing Upvc Windows upvc window repair
Carrol
Do You Know How To Explain Bmw Replacment Key To Your Boss Bmw replacement Key
Lavina
What The 10 Most Worst Reallife Sexdoll FAILURES Of All Time
Could Have Been Prevented Cheap Sex Doll (Images.Google.Com.Bo)
Akilah
20 Things You Need To Know About Good Online Shopping Sites Uk Moisture Protection Camera Storage
Cedric
What Is Avon Brochures Online’s History? History Of Avon Brochures
Online avon brochure online (Laura)
Phillip
Are You In Search Of Inspiration? Check Out Slot Demo Gratis Main Demo
Hollie
Guide To Situs Gotogel Terpercaya: The Intermediate Guide To Situs Gotogel
Terpercaya situs gotogel terpercaya (http://gsuso.ru/)
Hugh
Ford Key 101″The Ultimate Guide For Beginners ford kuga keys (John)
Leila
A Step-By-Step Guide To Choosing Your Real Sexdoll affordable Sex Doll
Marco
Sectional Couches For Sale: The Good And Bad About Sectional
Couches For Sale leather recliner couch
Jade
A Relevant Rant About Couches On Sale Modern Couch (https://Chessdatabase.Science)
Libby
Three Greatest Moments In Designer Handbags Green History Designer Handbags amazon
Kassie
See What Double Glazing Repairs Near Me Tricks The Celebs Are Using double glazing
repairs near me (dnpaint.co.kr)
Jacqueline
9 . What Your Parents Teach You About Upvc Window Repairs upvc window repairs (Aundrea)
Debora
The Best CSGO Case New Strategies To Transform Your Life prisma case –
Cornelius
–
Chance
The People Closest To Folding Treadmill Uk
With Incline Have Big Secrets To Share small space Treadmill with incline (76.biqund.com)
Evonne
The Worst Advice We’ve Ever Heard About Idn Play goblok
Mikki
You Are Responsible For A Double Glazed Repairs Near Me Budget?
12 Ways To Spend Your Money Double Glaze Door
Lyndon
20 Car Key Mobile Locksmith Websites Taking The Internet By Storm locksmith near me for cars cheap (Maurine)
Elsie
How To Build A Successful Car Key Auto Locksmith Entrepreneur Even If You’re Not Business-Savvy locksmiths near Me for cars
Shawnee
The Most Pervasive Problems In Accident Attorneys Industrial Accident Attorney
Kassie
10 Simple Steps To Start Your Own Mobile Car Door Lock Repair Business Car key Programming
Cortez
5 Killer Quora Answers To Treadmills Best Treadmills Best
Isidra
What’s The Job Market For Treadmills UK Reviews Professionals?
treadmills Uk reviews
Hugh
You’ll Never Be Able To Figure Out This Private Adhd Assessment Near Me’s Secrets Private Adhd Assessment
Tania
See What Treadmills Tricks The Celebs Are Using treadmill
Jerold
A Look At The Ugly Truth About Www Avon Uk Com Representative Login www Avon uk com representative login
Will
It’s Time To Expand Your Semi Truck Lawyer Options semi truck accident law Firm
Michael
Five Killer Quora Answers On Designer Handbags Large designer handbags large
Brent
10 Things We Love About Emergency Window Repair Window Repairs
Alba
How To Find The Perfect Double Glazed Window Repair On The
Internet window Repairs near me
Franziska
How Do You Know If You’re Prepared For Citroen C1 Spare Key Cost unlocking
Dirk
What’s The Current Job Market For Tier 2 Backlinks Professionals?
tier 2 backlink – https://www.youtube.com/ –
Pat
You’ll Never Guess This Upvc Window Repairs Near Me’s Tricks Upvc Window Repairs Near Me
Fredericka
8 Tips To Improve Your Sex Machines Price UK Game sex manchines
Madeline
10 Places To Find What Is The Best Online Shopping In Uk Countertop Convection Oven – Boyce,
Darla
Guide To Narrow American Fridge Freezer: The Intermediate Guide To Narrow
American Fridge Freezer narrow american fridge Freezer
Antonia
Bentley Key Fob Replacement Tools To Improve Your Everyday Lifethe Only Bentley Key Fob Replacement Trick That Every Person Must Be Able
To bentley key
Domingo
Tommy Hilfiger Bookbag Tools To Streamline Your Daily Life Tommy Hilfiger Bookbag
Trick That Every Person Should Learn Tommy Hilfiger Bookbag
Zac
4 Dirty Little Details About Bags Prada Industry Bags Prada
Industry prada bag sale
Leah
How To Get More Value Out Of Your Asbestos Attorney asbestos lawsuit
Herman
What’s The Job Market For Treadmill Near Me Professionals?
treadmill near me (https://topazdirectory.com/Listings12623021/tread-mills-is-the-next-hot-Thing-in-Tread-mills)
Tyson
Guide To Auto Ghost Immobiliser: The Intermediate Guide The Steps To Auto Ghost Immobiliser auto ghost immobiliser (https://cse.google.pl/url?sa=t&url=https://lively-bear-fhc422.mystrikingly.com/blog/10-unexpected-ghost-immobiliser-installer-tips)
Brock
It Is The History Of Real Life Sexdoll http://www.Topsadulttoys.uk
Isaac
You’ll Never Guess This Cheapest 12kg Washing Machine’s Tricks Cheapest 12Kg Washing Machine
Monroe
What’s The Fuss About 12 Kg Washing Machine Uk? quiet
Mari
10 Erroneous Answers To Common Anal Butt Plugs Questions Do You Know The Right Answers?
steel anal butt plug – shapiro-garcia-3.thoughtlanes.net –
Ronnie
15 Best Documentaries About Mesothelioma Compensation mesothelioma Case
Evelyne
Nine Things That Your Parent Teach You About Ferrari Ghost
Installer Ferrari Ghost Installer (https://Telegra.Ph/Where-Will-Ferrari-Ghost-Installer-One-Year-From-Now-08-06)
Marie
4 Dirty Little Secrets About Veleco Mobility And The Veleco Mobility Industry mobility scooter veleco
Kaitlyn
Nine Things That Your Parent Teach You About Window Pane Replacement
Window pane Replacement
Jasmin
It’s True That The Most Common Robot Vacuum Cleaner Debate It’s Not
As Black And White As You Might Think best robot vacuum for thick carpet – Cheri –
Jana
Five Killer Quora Answers On Spare Car Key Maker spare car key Maker
Sophie
9 . What Your Parents Teach You About Beko Washing Machines New beko Washing machines new
Jana
You’ll Never Guess This Replacement Window Handle’s Tricks replacement window handle (fpcom.co.Kr)
Elane
You’ll Never Guess This Birth Injury Attorney Fort Collins’s Tricks Birth injury Attorney fort collins
Rickey
Mesothelioma Settlement Tips From The Most Effective In The Industry Sequim Mesothelioma Lawyer
Beverly
A. The Most Common Tommy Hilfiger And Bags Debate Isn’t As Black And White As You Might Think Tommy hilfiger Bag Duffle
Milla
15 Mobility Scooter Servicing Near Me Benefits Everyone Should Be Able To
Where Can I Buy A Mobility Scooter Near Me
Jessika
Are You Responsible For An Upvc Window Repairs Budget?
10 Terrible Ways To Spend Your Money Window replacement
Judi
10 Reasons Why People Hate Auto Accidents Lawyer Auto Accidents Lawyer Auto Accident Attorneys In Houston
Adell
5 Killer Quora Answers On Nespresso Machines Compared nespresso machines compared
Hung
What Is Demo Slot And Why You Should Care slot Demo mirip asli
Modesto
12 Facts About Upvc Window Repairs To Get You Thinking About The Water Cooler upvc window repairs near me
Lance
20 Things You Need To Know About L30 Ultra Dreame near
Buster
The 12 Worst Types Of Tweets You Follow car remote programming locksmith near me (Penny)
Kala
7 Simple Secrets To Completely Enjoying Your Cerebral Palsy Attorneys Berlin cerebral Palsy lawsuit (https://Vimeo.com/706812693)
Jesenia
10 Unexpected Double Glazing Units Near Me Tips double Glazed unit replacement
Lien
20 Trailblazers Leading The Way In Locksmith Cars programming
Chas
16 Must-Follow Instagram Pages For Upvc Window Repairs
Marketers Window Repairs Near Me
Barry
How To Make A Successful Adult Toys For Women Instructions For
Homeschoolers From Home uk adult toys – Lyn,
Johnette
Car Key Replacement Audi: A Simple Definition Audi New Key
Michel
Five Killer Quora Answers On Cerebral Palsy Legal Cerebral Palsy
Felisha
The Secret Secrets Of Drip Machine drip coffee maker uk
Fleta
Why You Should Focus On Making Improvements To
Windows Leeds upvc window hinge repair leeds
Warren
Need Inspiration? Check Out Cheap Cases CSGO case operation bravo – 49.0.65.75,
Kayla
What Are The Myths And Facts Behind Railroad Injuries Lawyer
Railroad Injuries Lawsuit
Royce
30 Inspirational Quotes On Fiat 500 Keys fiat 500 remote key Programming
Lona
See What Dreame Bot L30 Ultra Tricks The Celebs Are Using dreame Bot l30 ultra
Bernd
Guide To Walking Pad Standing Desk: The Intermediate Guide To Walking
Pad Standing Desk walking pad standing desk (Lavada)
Arden
What’s The Job Market For 9kg Washing Machine Cheap Professionals Like?
9Kg Washing Machine Cheap
Maddison
The 10 Most Scariest Things About Motorcycle Accident Attorneys attorney
Kristine
Unexpected Business Strategies For Business
That Aided Trusted Online Shopping Sites For Clothes Succeed Vimeo.Com
Normand
15 Best Pinterest Boards Of All Time About Treadmill Under Desk walking treadmill with Desk
Zara
What To Do To Determine If You’re In The Right Place To Go After Auto
Accident Claim tuttle auto accident attorney
Zac
8 Tips To Enhance Your Window Refurbishment London Game replaced
Kazuko
This Is The Advanced Guide To Top Mesothelioma Lawyer alabama Mesothelioma lawyer
Lorrine
Ten Myths About Replacement Ford Fiesta Key Uk That Aren’t
Always The Truth Replacing Ford Key
Daisy
See What Seat Car Key Cover Tricks The Celebs Are Using seat car key (Mack)
Irwin
Ten Taboos About Window Repair Near You Shouldn’t Share On Twitter upvc window repair near me
Dewayne
9 Lessons Your Parents Taught You About Best Online Shopping Sites London Best Online Shopping Sites London
Emile
20 Resources To Help You Become Better At Designer Handbags For
Work online Designer handbag outlet (http://fpcom.co.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=1406997)
Paulina
How To Explain Tiktok Pornstar To Your Grandparents site
Frankie
Who’s The Most Renowned Expert On Window Repair Near?
window Repair near me
Hans
Mesothelioma Strategies From The Top In The Industry Mesothelioma
Attorney (Tujuan.Grogol.Us)
Cynthia
Why American-Style Fridge Freezers Isn’t A Topic That People Are Interested In.
best fridge freezers Uk
Joann
Ten Things Everyone Misunderstands About The Word “Double Glazed Windows Near Me.” Double glazed glass replacement
Jerrod
5 Motives Railroad Injuries Settlement Can Be A Beneficial Thing railroad injuries law firm (Arianne)
Jamal
10 Nespresso Coffee Pod Machine-Related Nespresso Coffee
Pod Machine-Related Projects That Will Stretch Your Creativity
nespresso lattissima
Jacquetta
The Little-Known Benefits To Auto Accident Case auto Accident law firm
Willie
Let’s Get It Out Of The Way! 15 Things About
Upvc Window Repairs We’re Tired Of Hearing upvc window Repairs Near me
Shantell
10 Things That Your Family Teach You About Replace Window Handles
replace window Handle
Helena
7 Simple Tips To Totally Intoxicating Your CSGO Gambling Sites case clutch [Reggie]
Ludie
Are You Sick Of Nespresso Krups Coffee Machine?
10 Inspirational Sources That Will Bring
Back Your Love Nespresso Pod machine
Newton
Melitta Coffee Dripper Tools To Ease Your Daily Life
Melitta Coffee Dripper Trick Every Individual Should Be Able To filter coffe machine (Hulda)
Tabatha
8 Tips To Increase Your Mesothelioma Lawsuit Game Mesothelioma Attorney
Kurtis
15 Things You Don’t Know About Window Repair Near window Repairs
Sherrill
Are You Getting The Most You Mobility Scooters Near Me For Sale?
used heavy Duty mobility Scooters for sale
Monika
Five Killer Quora Answers To Window Doctor Near Me window doctor near me (polimentosroberto.com.br)
Sonia
Unexpected Business Strategies For Business That Aided Car
Door Lock Repair Price Succeed car Lock system Repair
Jefferson
What Asbestos Lawyer Experts Would Like You To Know Asbestos Claim
Flynn
What Is The Heck Is Injury Compensation? Injury attorney (32.staikudrik.Com)